(717) 739-1091

Cheesemaker’s Choice Gift Box

$ 53.50

PLEASE NOTE: All orders are shipped within three business days via FedEx.  Please include any gift message in the ‘Order Details’ box upon checkout.

Let our cheesemakers bring our cheese shop to you!  You’ll enjoy a mix of our classic and limited-edition cheeses just in time for the holidays!  Your shipment will include a mix of 5 fresh and aged cheeses as well as our homemade pepper jam!  A great way for businesses to say ‘thank you’ to their patrons or employees, or to check that cheese lover off your holiday shopping list!!
See below for details on each cheese.
SKU: CHOICE Category:


The Cheesemaker’s Choice is a great gift and an ideal way to explore some of our classic & limited edition cheeses!  Your pack will include:
– Provola Riserva – A 6-month aged version of our popular Provola.  Our curd is hand-stretched by our cheesemakers, then brined and hung in our aging cave for at least 6 months.  The extended aging process removes excess moisture, resulting in smooth, firm consistency and a sharp, tangy flavor.  A great slice-and-eat cheese or perfect on a sandwich!  Approx. 8oz.
Provola Piccante Riserva – Certified Calabrian Peperoncino flakes are incorporated into our Provola during the stretching process before brining, and then the cheese is aged in our cave for at least 6 months.  A sharp tangy cheese with a kick!  Approx. 8oz.
“Tome” for the Holidays – This treat for the holiday season is a cooked, pressed-curd cheese made with the freshest raw milk from our family dairy farms in the Tome style.  This cheese takes on a straw-colored paste and rind with a rich savory flavor following 6 months in our aging cave.  Approx. 4oz.
Fresh Fior di Latte (cow’s milk mozzarella) – Hand-stretched cow’s milk mozzarella, made in the traditional Italian style without any vinegar or citric acid.  The result is a rich, creamy taste unlike any other mozzarella sold in stores.  Perfect for a seasonal caprese, baked pasta, or on pizza!  Approx. 8oz.
Fresh Ricotta (whey-based) – Perfect in a cannoli or just on its own for a protein-packed snack, this is not the same product as the milk-based ricotta you find in the supermarket!  Our ricotta is made by harvesting the whey from our cheesemaking and re-cooking (ricotta is Italian for “re-cooked”!) it to create this soft, custard-like cheese.  It’s smooth texture and delicious flavor make it perfect for both sweet and savory applications. (1-1.25 lbs. per basket)
– Included in all Gift Packs:  Homemade Pepper Jelly!  Made from sweet bell peppers & the perfect accompaniment to any of our cheeses!
**As available – substitutions may be made if one of these cheeses is out of stock.
Caputo Brothers Creamery uses only Animal Welfare Approved, non-GMO feed, pasture-based milk from local, family-owned dairy farms.  We are committed to paying a fair price to farmers for the high quality milk they produce!  All of our cheeses are naturally fermented, made without vinegar or citric acid.

Additional information

Weight 9.1 lbs
Dimensions 13 x 13 x 10 in